Emergency Management is a Local Responsibility

During recent testimony, Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Administrator Brock Long told Congress that state and local communities must do a better job of preparing for disaster response and must stop looking to FEMA as a first responder.

Since FEMA was created in 1979, the agency has consistently described its role as a coordinating agency, bringing together all federal agencies in support of state and local governments, who are responsible for disaster and emergency response. The National Response Framework, issued by FEMA in 2008 and updated in 2013, describes a tiered system for disaster response, in which the primary responsibility for response and recovery operations is vested in municipal or county governments.  When local resources are insufficient, assistance is provided by neighboring jurisdictions through mutual aid, or by the state. When state resources are insufficient, state officials can request assistance from FEMA.

Emergency managers understand this.  But over time, as FEMA has become heavily involved in high-profile disasters, the public – and many non-emergency management local officials – have begun to view disaster response as a federal responsibility.

So, Mr. Long is certainly correct in pointing out to lawmakers that FEMA is neither structured, resourced, prepared, nor equipped to serve as a first responder during disasters or large-scale emergencies.

Most local officials do understand their critical role, but many find it difficult to devote resources to preparation for worst-case scenarios that likely will never occur.  Most local safety forces are already stretched thin just handling the day-to-day calls for service that they receive.  There is little time for disaster response training and little funding for specialized disaster relief equipment.  One result is that federal grant funding, which increased significantly after the 9/11 attacks, has become the main source of emergency management funding for many local emergency management agencies.

In an era of increasing federal deficits, this is an unsustainable practice. While Emergency Management Performance Grant funding has remained steady, funding for the Homeland Security Grant Program has declined form $861 million in 2009 to $402 million in 2017.

And Administrator Long is correct, state and local emergency management agencies will need to live with reduced funding or identify local sources.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-congress-fema/fema-chief-questions-agencys-role-urges-more-local-response-idUSKBN1DU2KT

http://www.govtech.com/em/emergency-blogs/managing-crisis/Who-Should-Pay-for-070113.html

December 16, 2017

Safer Schools or a Safer Nation?

If we are interested in having a productive conversation about mass shootings in America – and I don’t for one moment believe that we are – the first thing we need to do is agree on what the actual problem is.

Right now, in the wake of the Parkland high school murders, there are two competing ideas.  One side believes that the problem is school safety, while the other side thinks the problem is safety in schools, churches, nightclubs, concerts, university classrooms, and everywhere else in America.

The difference in these views is significant.  If all you want to address is school shootings, then hardening schools might make sense. Even a crackpot idea like arming teachers might be worth discussing. On the other hand, if your goal is to make every place in America safer from mass casualty attacks from terrorists, disgruntled ex-employees, angry ex-spouses, and mentally disturbed ex-students, then hardening schools and arming teachers are ineffective options, and your discussion must be much more wide-ranging.

In general, the most effective voices for action – led by Parkland survivors –  are focusing their efforts on school safety. Unfortunately, school safety is just one element of a much more complicated problem, which includes shootings in churches, nightclubs, university classrooms, country-western concerts, army bases, county offices, and everywhere else.

 

April 26, 2018